Thursday, October 8, 2009

Issues with "True Blood" - Free Evil Faery Anthology - "Supernatural" Thursday



Carolyn Cane is having a lively discussion at The Trillionth Page about Charlaine Harris's Sookie Stackhouse/Southern Vampire series vs. "True Blood," directed by Alan Ball. "To Mark and me, Alan Ball deciding not to taint himself by watching Buffy is like a writer saying she wants to write a great classic novel, but not wanting to taint herself by reading Shakespeare, Dostoyevsky, Jane Austen, Graham Greene, etc. In fact, that's barely a metaphor--it's exactly what Joss Whedon is to TV."

I really like the Southern Vampire books, but I was predisposed to dislike the TV series because: 1) I've disliked everything else Alan Ball has done; 2) he had a snotty "Buffy, who?" attitude that I found ignorant and disrespectful of Joss Whedon's amazing and smart series; 3) the casting was so off, from bleached out Anna Paquin as Sookie to the lack of authentic Southerners; and 4) Ball discussed his decision to crank up violence and graphic sex to draw in a male audience, not because it served or advanced the story.

But I tried to watch the show anyway. I tried a few times. The cheeze factor is ridiculous. Bad make-up, bad accents, bad set design, corny dialogue, strange casting choices. I think it's okay to remake something as your own. However, one hopes that you can be as good as the original, or improve upon it, not that you will use it just to get an audience base and warp it completely. Why not, then, just start with a new concept?

But that's just me -- so don't leave an angry comment. I know my tastes are specific. Everyone else loved Alan Ball's "Six Feet Under" and "American Beauty." Me, I'll stick to Charlaine Harris's novels where I can really imagine a small Southern town infested with paranormals.

Fans of the series may be interested in an interview with Stephen Moyer, who plays Bill Compton in "True Blood." "Well, the character I played in Ultraviolet loved being a vampire and the character this time is somebody who struggles with it. He struggles with the fact that he has to feed on humans. He's trying to live a decent life and is very conflicted and tortured which is great fun to play." (BBC News)


Read about Annette McCleave's new novel, Drawn Into Darkness, and enter a contest to win a copy. "The hero Lachlan starts off the story in the guise of a priest. Yup, black suit, white collar, and big silver cross around his neck. Now, he’s not actually a priest, but the heroine Rachel doesn’t know that." (Yankee Book Reviews)


What do you do if you like terrifying faeries AND free reads? As part of a Halloween celebration, Juno Books' is offering a free ebook, Scary Faeries: Four Fearful Tales of the Fey.


"SUPERNATURAL" THURSDAY



I don't know if I'm terrified or delighted that Paris Hilton will be on "Supernatural" tonight. I'm definitely intrigued. John Kubincek at Buddy TV has a list of demands for this episode, and #1 is that Hilton says, "That's hot." "This is essentially Paris Hilton's catchphrase, so I definitely expect to hear these two words come from her mouth. Bonus points if Dean says it."

Eric Kripke, the show's creator, says that Hilton plays "a monster who takes the form of Paris Hilton… It’s a fun, irreverent episode about modern celebrity. [Fans] should withhold judgment until they see it.” (Entertainment Weekly)

Here's a clip from tonight's show. "Super famous, super crazy ghosts killing their super fans." Sounds super!




GRATUITOUS VIDEOS OF THE DAY

This is all angsty, not my usual thing, but you may like it.



This is more to my taste.



I'm sure Alex O'Loughlin fans will be happy that the actor who played Mick St. John on "Moonlight" is back in a new series, "Three Rivers." Here's a video you'll enjoy, but it's got some R-rated scenes and I don't know what offends people or not, so you can see it on YouTube.

10 comments:

Carolyn Crane said...

Hey Marta! Thanks for the shout!

Chris said...

You nailed it, Marta - that's why I don't want to watch True Blood. I have the Sookie locations and characters all nicely developed in my mind's eye. I don't want to mess that up with someone else's vision.

Kristen Painter said...

I am with you on the books vs the series. That show isn't even in the same league as the books.

PeaceLove&Pat said...

Agreed. On the casting choices. Seriously Anna Pacquin is sooo not Sookie material, everything is so off. Completely ruined the Sookie-Eric moments. I take it as an insult that he is butchering the original parts of the book. But I watch in anyway in the hopes of separating the book from the TV series and to support Evan Rachel Wood. Lol

Marta said...

Hi, everyone! I think if someone hasn't read the books first, the show is probably fine. But I had a very definite idea of the town and Sookie...not to mention Bill and Eric.

Some of my friends love this show, so I really have tried more than once to like it.

ParaJunkee said...

You know... I'm not a prude, but the violence/sex of TruBlood turned me off, and especially since my hubby would look over at me and go - "this is what you are reading!!???"

Nicole_Hadaway said...

I don't have HBO and therefore haven't seen True Blood, so maybe I shouldn't comment, but I just had to say that anyone who disses Joss Whedon is questionable in my book.

Lexie said...

I dislike everything Alan Ball has done before as well, but wanted to give True Blood a shot (cause I like Anna Paquin, more's my pity now). I liked the Sookie books up until around Book 5 or so, then dropped off reading them since I was losing interest in Sookie going through different boyfriends and all.

I don't think the 'enjoy' is the right word for how I view True Blood as a show. I enjoy pieces of True Blood--Lafayette, Eric, Jason if he doesn't open his mouth, but overall I don't care for it that much, though I do get a hoot out of watching it with my dad and the two of us cackling over the ridiculousness of it all (I do like the Jessica/Hoyt romance, I won't lie, it was so sweet).

But honestly, did Ball have to say he wouldn't watch Buffy with so much dismissiveness? How does he get off doing that--especially given the fact most of his audience probably GREW UP watching Buffy as their vampire staple. that's really unprofessional and rude in my opinion.

Ro said...

Marta,

Couldn't agree more with what you wrote about True Blood! Dead Until Dark has been my favorite book since I first read it and now I can't believe what they turned the books into... I don't even mean the plot changes - obviously it's impossible to avoid these - but the whole atmosphere of the books has been completely destroyed for me... And Sookie - I adored the way she was portrayed in books but now? She seems like such a hot-headed, impolite, loud and obnoxious person! And honestly how much sex scenes can you fit into a 50 minutes episode? I'd hate to be rude but is it still sci-fi/urban mystery or simply VampPorn?

Marta said...

Hi, Ro! You know, the more you love a series, the harder it is to see it changed in a TV or movie adaptation.

Although Alan Ball claimed to love the books, I don't think he really did. I think he saw them as a template for his own vision...which is inferior to Charlaine Harris's vision. Which would have been okay if he'd just come up with his own vampire/sex/sex/vampire theme.

On the other hand, his show has introduced a lot of people to the books.